Hello! I am back. It's been a while - life completely sucked my will (and even ability) to write about books. I have only read about six over the last two months, which is completely out of character for me. Fear not, though - I have opinions about these six books which I am quite happy to share!
First up, a quickie review. I was quite excited to get Liane Moriarty's new book Truly Madly Guilty, as I really loved Big Little Lies. Truly Madly Guilty is the story of three couples who attend a fateful barbecue in which An Event occurs. I was really looking forward to reading this book! Unfortunately, this books sucks and it's pretty easy to identify why: bloat and consequence.
The book is told in two time frames centred around the Event, with alternating chapters set before and after. This is not an effective technique, as this book is so long that I started to get frustrated that I was reading so much about an incident without being told what the bloody incident was! The book could have lost 200 pages without them being missed and the whole story would have been more engaging (word bloat). There are about ten characters who get point-of-view chapters and involved back stories. This is too many points of view (character bloat). What's more, everyone has an issue - this book contains a hoarder, someone with OCD, alcoholics, mental illness, job insecurity, musical genius, stripping, cutting - too many issues (issue bloat). So bloated, so annoying.
While the bloat made the book frustrating to read, it could have been fixed with a decent (albeit severe) edit. The second problem is harder to fix. The truth is that the incident, the huge event that drives the plot, is just not that big a deal. Sure, there was danger, but [spoiler alert] everyone was fine! There were no ongoing consequences, so why was everyone so het up about it? Every single adult in this book massively overreacted in a way that is completely unbelievable.
So, basically, this book is not good. However, every author gets one free pass. Hopefully, she will be back to form with the next book and we can all pretend this one didn't happen.
Showing posts with label australian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label australian. Show all posts
Wednesday, August 3, 2016
Wednesday, July 17, 2013
Into My Arms by Kylie Ladd (2013)
There has been a bit of buzz around Kylie Ladd's new book Into My Arms, so I was excited to pick it up from the library yesterday. I love a book where you can really sink your teeth into the ideas and characters featured and I thought this book club darling was going to be the next dinner-party must-read. Into My Arms opens strongly, when the impetuous headstrong Skye, who is dating Hamish, meets teacher Ben Cunningham at a school. Skye falls in love with Ben and leaves Hamish. However, problems arise when Skye introduces Ben to her mother Nora and her gay brother Arran, who has just broken up with Mark, who cheated on him, and Nora realises that Ben and Skye are actually brother and sister - Ben was conceived using fertilised eggs left over after Nora and her husband Charlie, who just died of dementia, used IVF to have Arran and Skye. Ben didn't know he wasn't his parents' genetic child and becomes estranged from his mother Mary, although he stays in touch with his sister Kirra.
Sound complicated? That summary sums up just about every single problem with this very average book. After its strong beginning, the story just goes nowhere. The characters lack any depth at all, do not develop over the course of the novel and there are so many different characters with a stake in this story it's overwhelming, especially since their narrative voices are exactly the same.
On top of the laundry list of characters, this book is not afraid to acknowledge multiple ideas. As well as the incest storyline, there is a dementia storyline, a gay storyline, a cheating storyline, a squatting/freegan storyline, an asylum seeker storyline, a widow storyline and, just so nothing gets left out, a religious storyline as well. On top of that there are the broader overarching themes of family, motherhood, home and belonging. Simply put, that's too many storylines! Ladd would have been much better served to strip back the unnecessary stuff and focus on the important characters and stories so we care about the people she is writing about. Instead, she makes something a big deal - like Charlie having dementia - that has absolutely nothing to do with the rest of the story. This is Basic Writing 101 - if it doesn't add to the story, take it out. What's even worse is that Ladd's metaphors are so laboured it's almost painful to read - for example, after finding out that Skye is his sister, Ben has explosive diarrhoea and the only thing he had to wipe his arse on is the letter from the genetics company telling him the results of the sibling test. You have seriously got to be kidding.
There are interesting ideas in this book. The consequences of IVF and sperm/egg donation are real - there are concerns about genetic siblings hooking up because they don't realise they are related. The integration of asylum seekers into Australian society and the processing of refugee visas is a big problem. It is horrible to lose a family member to dementia and it must be awful to discover that your partner is cheating on you. However, you get absolutely nothing from reading this book that you wouldn't get from reading a really detailed plot summary, so read a couple of reviews of Into My Arms that contain spoilers so you know enough about it to get by at dinner parties and spend your time reading another better book instead.
Monday, May 13, 2013
High Sobriety by Jill Stark (2013)
“I’m the binge-drinking health reporter. During the week I
write about Australia’s booze-soaked culture. At the weekends, I write myself
off.”
Years ago, I remember reading this article by the Age’s
health reporter Jill Stark. As someone for whom binge-drinking has been a
regular part of socialising – not as in I binge-drink a lot, but regular heavy
weekend drinking has definitely been acceptable and encouraged in many of the
groups I have spent time with – it certainly resonated with me. Following on
from the success of that article, this book details the year-long break from
alcohol taken by the life-of-the-party Jill Stark. Her personal experiences are
interspersed with really confronting and disturbing data about the damage that
alcohol abuse can have on a personal, social and cultural level.
As a Scotswoman living in Australia, Stark comes from two
cultures where drinking is seen as an integral part of belonging. Stark is
called ‘unAustralian’ for not drinking and her friends joke that her Australian
citizenship certificate will come with a six-pack of VB. However, Stark finds
that Australia’s history with alcohol is not one of larrikin good-natured mateship
but a more complicated relationship of politics, marketing and regulatory
factors (such as the famous 6 o’clock swill). Although we may believe that
alcohol is fundamental to the formation of Australia as we know it, our current
levels of drinking are a recent development that is constantly being reinforced
by marketing, for example CUB’s ‘Raise a Glass’ promotion. The recent increase
in alcohol sale and abuse has not been matched by an increase in funding for
treatment and recovery and, according to the picture painted by the experts
Stark interviews, the problem is only going to get worse as baby boomers take
their problem drinking habits with them into retirement homes.
There were two things I found incredibly disturbing in this
book. Firstly, I was shocked at the long-term ramifications of heavy drinking physically
– for women, a considerable increase in the risk of breast cancer and for both
sexes, an all-over increase in cancer risk – as well the considerable
psychological damage that can be done to memory and behaviour. Secondly, I was
not aware of the role of industry and government in the ever-increasing
ubiquity of alcohol. Over the last ten years there has been a massive increase
in the number of places that sell alcohol and the hours in which alcohol is
available for purchase. Advertising within the industry is self-regulated,
which in practical terms means very little regulation at all. Alcohol is a huge
part of sporting events and, disturbingly, a vital part of sports funding. The
AFL even has an ‘official beer’, which seems even more ridiculous when Stark
points out that alcohol is totally non-conducive to elite sports performance
and therefore not used by the athletes whose performances are linked by
marketing with booze. It’s a really disturbing situation.
I really enjoyed reading this book. Jill Stark has a frank,
interesting writing style and she seems like (ironically) she would be a great
person to go and have a drink with. Having completed both Dry July and FebFast,
a lot of what she found was true to my experience – the fear of going without
alcohol tends to be a lot worse than the reality. We are still us without a
drink. Yet just as nature abhors a vacuum, Australians are terrified by a
non-drinker and dealing with talking
about not-drinking is definitely more painful than the not-drinking is. I also
agree that sometimes we drink because we’re bored – we’re at a terrible party
or there’s nothing on TV so we crack open a bottle of wine. However, my
experience of problem drinking is not the same as Stark’s – I don’t know many
people in their mid-30s who go out and have massive nights every week
(although, based on the statistics she presented, it seems to be a huge problem
with younger people). In my experience it’s the nights in that are the issue –
the one glass of wine with dinner that transitions into a bottle three or four
times a week. The people I know who say they drink too much drink too much at
home, not out and about. I also think because it’s really clear that Stark has
a problem with alcohol abuse (although she doesn’t believe she’s an alcoholic
because she was able to give it up quite easily), it becomes easy to say ‘Oh,
that’s not like me and my friends – we never vomit when we go out’. Because
she’s worse, our situation seems not
that bad.
That said, I think this is an important book for people to
read, not just for the information it contains but because it’s an engaging,
interesting account of a woman’s experiences with alcohol and a discussion of two
societies (Scottish and Australian) who are reaching crisis point with their
relationship to alcohol. While it suffers from the same problems of many
first-person memoirs (overuse of the pronoun ‘I’ and the phrase ‘tears streamed
down my/her/his/our face/s’), it is still entertaining and thought-provoking. I
give it four stars.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

