Showing posts with label 2012. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2012. Show all posts

Thursday, August 22, 2013

The American Way of Eating by Tracie McMillan (2012)


I started reading this book after being intrigued a Salon piece written by a journalist (Tracie McMillan) who goes undercover to investigate the field-to-plate journey of food in America. I enjoyed Nickel and Dimed and I found the article well written and intriguing, so I was looking forward to this deeper picture of America’s relationship with food this book would provide.

However, I wish I had not wasted my time. White female privileged smug middle-class journalist Tracie McMillan decides to go investigate three aspects of the food industry – agriculture, distribution and preparation – by pretending to be a poor person and working as a labourer, at Walmart and in the kitchen at Applebees. This is similar to  what Barbara Ehrenreich did in Nickel and Dimed. The difference between Ehrenreich and McMillan’s books is that Ehrenreich acknowledges her privilege and states on a number of occasions that she understands that what she is doing is at best an imitation of the life of an actual poor person. McMillan not only doesn’t seen to understand her privilege, her poverty tourism actually causes harm to the very people her book seeks to give a voice to.

For example, McMillan’s first job is working in the fields in California. She concocts a not-very-believable reason for why an educated, well-spoken white woman is looking for manual labour and then proceeds to find a job, aiming to live on the money she earns from her own labour. The first problem with this is that the first two places she lives in are owned by friends or acquaintances of hers and she doesn’t have to pay rent. Her privilege, as evidenced by her strong social network, is already providing an (unacknowledged by her) benefit to her that the people whose lives she is investigating do not have. Through her neighbour, who lives with six other people in a two-bedroom trailer that she pays rent for, she finds a a job picking grapes. In this job, pickers work in groups of three and are paid on the number of boxes (cajas) of grapes the group can pick. Due to her inexperience, McMillan can only fill nine boxes, meaning her group members earned over 30% less than they normally would. Even though she did picked fewer grapes than others, the payment is divided three ways equally. She says: “There’s only one word to define what just happened: charity. And I know I am in no position to refuse it.” YES YOU ARE! You have an education and a strong social network and a well-paying job and an apartment that you live in on your own in New York City. It is reprehensible that your little games of poverty tourism literally took food out of the mouths of people who need it much, much more than you do. Tracie McMillan, you should be ashamed of yourself.

It doesn’t get any better. To study the distribution of food, McMillan gets a job at Walmart. She manages to find a place to rent where the landlord provides her with food staples – more free stuff. She comes up short on her rent because she has been going out for sushi, so she puts the difference on her credit card. Heads up, Tracie, the reason you were able to go out for sushi is because you are able to do things like put the rent on your credit card and then pay your credit card using your regular job. Actual poor people don’t do things like that, because if they did they would actually get evicted and not be able to call on their extensive social network for free housing or to just, you know, return to their NY apartment. When McMillan’s sister gets cross at her when Tracie says she “can’t afford” to go to a Christmas party which involves baking two dozen cookies, I had to stop reading for a while until I calmed down in order to prevent me throwing the book at the wall. McMillan’s sisters are a lot more refrained with her than I am with mine – if either of them had pulled that crap with me I would have sat them down and had a serious conversation with them about privilege and being an obnoxious dick. After the cookie party, McMillan decides she’s had enough of playing poor and quits her job and I quit reading the book.

Investigative journalists are important. They can provide a window into another way of life and expose, like Ehrenreich did, the appalling conditions some people work under and the human cost of the first-world consumer life we live. Tracie McMillan is a talented writer and the research in this book was excellent. But her particular type of privileged poverty tourism that caused harm to those she was aiming to write about is appalling. I give this book one star.


Monday, January 14, 2013

The Marriage Plot by Jeffrey Eugenides


Like with The Chaperone, I am again only reading now what everyone was reading last year (or the year before last? I am so out of touch) – Jeffrey Eugenides’ third book, The Marriage Plot. The eponymous marriage plot is the term for the trope used by authors where the plot revolves around who a heroine will marry. This book asks if, in a time where women can be financially and socially independent and divorce is easily accessible, does the marriage plot have a place in literature?

Based on this text, the answer is a resounding no. The book opens on graduation day at Brown College in the ‘80s. Madeline has woken up hungover in last night’s clothes, which are marked with a suspicious stain. Over the first few chapters there are parents, gowns, obligations both fulfilled and unfulfilled and we are introduced to the subjects of our marriage plot: the beautiful Madeline, tortured Leonard and earnest Martin (reportedly based on Jonathon Franzen, David Wallace Foster and the author respectively). Martin loves Madeline, Madeline loves Leonard and Leonard isn’t in a position to really love anyone. More on that later.

The first section is mainly Madeline’s story and I devoured it. It’s not that Madeline’s a particularly likeable character but moments of this part felt so true – like the contradictory feelings of guilt and pleasure you have when you spend time with someone who likes you but you don’t like them back but you like the feeling of them liking you which in turns makes you feel like a bad person. Or that moment where some guy in a tutorial is being a complete wanker and you look around expecting to find the group rolling their eyes and see that everyone else is enraptured and you’re the only one who can see the ridiculousness of the situation. There’s lots of discussions about books and theory which I, as an English graduate loved (although I didn’t study literature so some of it was gibberish to me), but I did wonder if someone who wasn’t familiar with postmodernism and literary theory would give enjoy the book at all. I am using semiotics in my thesis and I loved the scenes that featured the class discussions, particularly Madeline’s relief when she finds a writer whose sentences follow on logically from each other (postmodern writing is notoriously dense). The first 125 pages of The Marriage Plot is fabulous and enjoyable and exactly I expected from the author of a great novel like Middlesex. It was great!

I just wish I’d stopped reading on page 126. After the characters left college, I can’t put my finger on exactly what happened but the story got boring. Mitchell goes to Europe and then India to find himself. Leonard has a bipolar episode and is hospitalised, then Madeline and Leonard to go Cape Cod so he can do a postgrad research fellowship. The focus moves from Madeline and the marriage plot onto Martin and Leonard’s personal journeys. The thing is, though, it’s actually not very interesting to read about self-conscious privileged educated white men not do much except reflect on themselves and change geographical location. One of the main criticisms levelled against The Marriage Plot is that it’s pretentious. I didn’t feel it was pretentious as much as it was indulgent – indulgent in length and in its treatment of its male characters (to quote Woody Allen, it suffered from the three esses – self-indulget, sophomoric and solipsistic). I skimmed the last 200 pages, skipping Mitchell’s Eat Pray Ponder Indian journey in full. It was a struggle to make it to the end of the book and one I probably wouldn’t have done if it wasn’t a Eugenides novel – there was always a faint hope it would improve. It didn’t. My recommendation is to stop at 126 pages and read about the rest on Goodreads – that’s exactly what I wish I’d done.

Eugenides pulls off an efficient and effective feminist bait-and-switch with this novel. Books with a marriage plot have women and their social and economic roles and power at their centre. Eugenides opens a book with a modern-day marriage plot with a strong and interesting female protagonist but, after the trio graduate, Madeline shifts from having a voice and agency to being defined solely by her role as love object, nurse, wife and daughter. The marriage plot in The Marriage Plot is not a love triangle but a power struggle with a woman as the object of exchange and possession. I’m giving this book three stars  - five stars for its brilliant beginning minus two stars for the woeful ending and hidden misogyny.

Saturday, December 1, 2012

Autumn Laing by Alex Miller


Alex Miller is one of Australia’s most famous and awarded literary writers yet, for some reason, I’d never read any of his work. When, after reading yet another glowing review of his most recent novel Autumn Laing I saw that very same book on display at the library, I figured the universe was telling me it was time to fill this literary hole of knowledge so I picked up the book and took it home with me.

The eponymous Autumn Laing is loosely based on Sunday Reed who, with her husband John, ran a kind of artists community at what is now the Heide Art Gallery. Sunday Reed had an affair with Sidney Nolan, the famous Australian painter (and apparently is rumoured to have painted parts of his work). In Autumn Laing, Autumn is at the end of her life, reflecting on her two great loves, the talented artist Pat Donlan (Sidney Nolan) and the somewhat bland Arthur Laing.

I am deeply torn on my opinion of this book. If I were do a pros and cons list, each column would have the exact same amount of items in it. The language was lovely and the book was very well written. BUT it did seem to take a long time to get anywhere. Some of the paragraphs were over two pages long and occasionally I found myself skimming rather than reading every word. The female characters in this book are written exceptionally well, in fact better than the male characters, which surprised me given that the book is written by a man. In particular, the essence of 80-plus-year-old Autumn Laing is captured spectacularly (although, honestly, I could have done with a little less talk about farting). BUT the character of Autumn Laing reminded me a lot of my own grandmother, with (unfortunately) her tendency to tell really really long and rambling stories with little temporal or internal consistency. The descriptions of Australia and Melbourne were very vivid BUT omigod the foreshadowing was ridiculously excessive. From about the second page we are told repeatedly that something happened in the Australian outback but the ‘something happened’ doesn’t actually happen until 30 pages before the end and, by that stage, I just really wanted it to happen so I wouldn’t have to read the dire foreshadowing anymore! One positive for the book that doesn’t have a negative balancing item is the exploration of the restrictions placed on the women in this book due to their gender. If Sunday Reed had been born in a different time, she would have lived a very different life.

I did enjoy this book. It definitely inspired me to read more about Sunday Reed and the Heide artist colony – I do feel I have a special connection with the gallery since I lost a baby shoe there. It was also a real pleasure to read a literary novel that didn’t contain a scene about a privileged white man masturbating! But I am reluctant to recommend it as it is a very long book which, in itself, is not a bad thing, but it’s a long book that feels like a long book, if that makes any sort of sense! Reading this book took effort and required work and, if you like your books effortless and enrapturing, Autumn Laing is not for you. Also, this book has a lot of characters who commit suicide in it, which may be a trigger for some. 

A solid literary effort - I give it three stars.

Thursday, October 4, 2012

The House of Memories by Monica McInerney


I have had mixed opinions of Monica McInerney's previous books. I liked The Alphabet Sisters, loved Those Faraday Girls, thought At Home with the Templetons was interesting but uneven and hated Lola's Secret (dear publishing gods, please spare us from any more books that center on wise, all-knowing elderly women who know how to use technology and are able to use their wisdom and all-knowingness to communicate with young people. These women are unsufferable and make me want to throw things - ie the book I'm reading that features these irritating protagonists - at the wall. Thank you.), so I wasn't sure what to expect from this book. Either way, McInerney has a nice, easy writing style, so I figured even if her new book wasn't great it would be a relaxing way to spend a few hours away from the high stress levels of my everyday life ("CAPS LOCK IS HOW I FEEL ALL THE TIME, RICK!"). Boy, was I wrong.

The House of Memories opens with a chapter detailing the childhood of Ella Fox/Baum/O'Hanlon and the special relationship she has with her uncle, Lucas. After we wade through the standard broken-home childhood tale (parents divorce, remarry, step-brother, new baby, jealously, et cetera cetera et cetera) we get to the crux of the story - Ella's baby has died. The book then separates into chapters told from the point of view of different characters, with some (very annoying) email chapters and others alternating between the first and third chapter.

I have no problem with having multiple narrators, even if (as is clearly signposted in this book ALL THE TIME for the benefit of those who have memory problems, I imagine) these narrators are unreliable. I have no problem with epistolary writing - The Guernsey Literary Potato Peel Pie Society is one of my favourite books. What I do have a problem with is books that are so predictable that, after reading the third chapter, it is possible to plot what happens in every chapter until the end. There is pleasure in reading genre fiction - it's nice to know that the right couple will get together in the end in a romance novel, for example - so I understand that books can be about the journey rather than the destination. But if both the journey and the destination suck...step away from the book.

I am a bit bummed about contemporary fiction at the moment. Ian McEwan's Sweet Tooth was a massive disappoint. I started Zadie Smith's new book NW but abandoned it because of the stream-of-consciousness writing style. This book completely sucked. Am I picking bad books, or has the standard of published works dropped recently? I'm about to start Gone Girl, which has received great reviews. If that sucks as well, I might stop reading anything published after the turn of the century and stick to books that have passed the test of time!